China's Dams Threaten Mekong, Conservationists Say
Heda Bayron
Hong Kong
19 Jul 2004, 12:20 UTCChina
is harnessing the power of water to satisfy its growing demand for energy.
But some conservationists warn that China's quest is damaging one of the
world's longest and most resource-rich rivers, the Mekong.
Some 60 million people along the Mekong's 4,800 kilometer path depend on
the river for transportation and food. The Mekong originates on the high
Tibetan plateau, winding through China, Burma, Laos, Thailand, Cambodia, and
Vietnam before reaching the South China Sea.
Recently, water levels in several parts have dropped to record lows and
the fish catch has fallen.
The findings are causing controversy about the causes, with many
conservationists saying the damage is due to hydroelectric dams, especially
China's two huge dams in the upper part of the Mekong.
Marc Goichot, coordinator of the Mekong river project of the conservation
group World Wildlife Fund in Cambodia, explains that upstream dams can
change the main qualities of the river, such as its temperature, rate of
flow, and the amount of oxygen in the water. It also affects the migration
of fish.
"The reservoir is trapping the sediment and the sediment is very
important for the stability dynamics of the river downstream. If the water
has less sediment, it is more erosive," says Mr. Goichot. "So the shape of
the riverbed downstream will be affected."
China started building large dams on the Upper Mekong, in southwestern
Yunnan province, near the border with Laos, in the mid-1980s. The government
plans to build eight of them, and has already completed two dams, Manwan and
Dachaosan. Work on a third one (Xiaowan) is in progress.
China needs the dams to create enough electricity to feed its voracious
economic growth.
Experts say the deep gorges of the Upper Mekong, known in China as
Lancang Jiang, are geographically well suited for hydroelectric power
generation.
The Mekong River Commission or M.R.C., an organization backed by all
Mekong countries except China and Burma, says the completion of the China's
Manwan Dam in 1993 is linked to irregular water levels detected in Chiang
Saen, Thailand, 200 kilometers from the Chinese border.
Environmental specialists from the M.R.C. say the variation in water
levels has spoiled aquatic life and decreased sediment. In addition, the
nutrient-rich sediments spread by annual floods fertilize farmland in the
Lower Mekong delta. But the M.R.C. says the recent low water levels in the
Mekong were the result of drought, not China's dams.
Chinese officials defend their dams, saying they help prevent flooding in
the Mekong delta during the wet season.
Feng Yan, a professor at the Asian International Rivers Center of Yunnan
University, says China's upstream dams trap water in reservoirs during the
wet season, which can then be used during the dry season. Downstream
countries then get water in the dry season, and China gets electricity when
demand is highest. "Maybe in the future other dams will be built and there
will be more water downstream in the Mekong River."
Conservationists say it is not only China's dams that are the problem;
several large dams in Mekong tributaries are in the planning stage and could
further harm the river system.
Laos is building a large hydropower dam, Nam Theun II. Much of the power
generated from this project will be sold to Thailand. Environmental
activists warn that Nam Theun Two will change the natural flow and ecology
of the Xe Bang Fai River, which flows into the Mekong in Laos.
Earlier this month, the Vietnamese government approved the construction
of the Ninh Binh Two hydroelectric plant project in northern Vietnam.
Witoon Permponsacharoen is director of the Thai environmental activist
group, TERRA. He says that in the past, economists in the Mekong Delta
promoted a model of regional development that relied on hydroelectric dams.
He says that since that time, the damage to the Mekong has become apparent.
"The model that believed that economic growth will be a regional
phenomenon," he says. "The dam industry is looking at the Mekong as a very
attractive business area."
Conservationists say halting the building of dams will not solve the
problem if countries replace hydroelectric power with something less
environmentally friendly. They say countries should pursue alternative power
sources if they want to preserve their river of life.