| PHNOM PENH, Cambodia (AP) -
Cambodia's new jumbo cabinet with 186 ministers is raising concerns
among Cambodians about a bloated bureaucracy and greater corruption in
one of the poorest countries in the world.
The cabinet's size has wiped out the relief many felt when the
country's two top parties resolved a one-year political deadlock
during which Cambodia had no working government following inconclusive
elections last July.
"I'm more worried than happy," said Hang Puthea, director of the
election monitoring group Nicfec. "After solving a crisis of having no
government, we now have one of loosely linked parts that will just
make things more complicated and even worse."
The new coalition government was formed after Prime Minister Hun
Sen's Cambodian People's Party persuaded its rival, the royalist
Funcinpec party, to become a partner, partly by creating additional
ministerial posts to accommodate it.
In the new cabinet, the prime minister is assisted by seven deputy
prime ministers, up from two in the previous government. It has 15
senior ministers with no portfolios, 28 ministers and 135 deputy
ministers for a total of 186 positions - well over twice as many as
before, and 63 more than the number of seats in the National Assembly.
Most of the new appointees are unlikely to have any real duties,
but merely add another layer of bureaucracy that can create more
paperwork for any kind of official task, Hang Puthea said.
The CPP had no choice but to accommodate Funcinpec after winning
only 73 seats in the 123-member National Assembly, short of the
two-thirds required to govern alone. Funcinpec has 26 seats.
In Cambodia, as in many poor countries, working for the government
can be lucrative despite low salaries. Extracting unofficial payments
for processing paperwork - from traffic tickets to million-dollar
contracts - is a source of income for many civil servants.
The bribes also provide the lifeblood for political parties as part
of the patronage system. But it is a burden for the average citizen in
a country where nearly half of the 13 million people get by on less
than $1 US ($1.31 Cdn) a day.
Payments by companies to public officials "are frequent, mostly or
always required to 'get things done,"' according to a World Bank study
last year about Cambodia's investment climate.
The study, which found the country's "bribe tax" among the worst in
the world, says bribes in the manufacturing and service sectors are
estimated at about $120 million ($157 million) a year.
"We would hope that the new bureaucratic structure doesn't create a
new barrier to foreign direct investment," said outgoing Canadian
Ambassador Stefanie Beck.
Chea Sina, a 38-year-old policeman and father of two who earns
90,000 riel ($30 Cdn) a month, said the scores of new jobs at the top
dashed his hopes for a pay hike any time soon.
"With more people (in office) like this, more money from the
national budget will obviously have to be spent on their salaries,
allowances, office facilities, fuel for their cars," Chea Sina said.
"I have wished for pay raise, but I have little hope about that
now," he said.
CPP-Funcinpec coalitions with the same party leaders also ran the
two previous governments, since 1993.
After last July's election, Funcinpec vowed not to join a
government again led by Hun Sen, the formerly Communist prime
minister, accusing him of corruption and autocratic behaviour.
But with its popularity waning, Funcinpec decided to join the
coalition because "they just want to have a piece of the pie," said
Cambodia scholar Stephen Heder of London's School of Oriental and
African Studies.
Heder, however, said focusing too much on the unwieldy bureaucracy
overlooks a bigger problem - the interconnected network of economic,
bureaucratic and military power that has made Hun Sen's Cambodian
People's Party unbeatable.
"These guys, their friends and their cronies are here to stay.
There's no possibility of alternation of power," he said. "So, there's
no real democracy in that sense."
Suong Pin, a 39-year-old motorcycle-taxi driver in Phnom Penh who
cast his vote in the 2003 election wishing for "something new," admits
to disappointment in seeing the same old faces in the new government.
But he has not given up hope.
"I will vote again in the new elections in the future until we get
good and clean leaders. I believe good will prevail over bad," said
Suong Pin, who makes about 4,000 riel ($1.33) a day. |