Our second stop was Phnom Penh, Cambodia. One of the Thai companies
we met with when commenting on doing business in Cambodia and the skills of
Cambodian industry and labor ad-libbed that “the time
difference between Thailand and Cambodia is thirty years.” In reality,
although there is definitely a difference in levels of technology and
training between the two countries, there is no actual time difference
and the flight time is only one hour. Arriving in Phnom Penh Pochetong
Airport, we were struck by the new international terminal, which is
modern, new and well run. Visas are issued on arrival - $20 for
tourist visas and $25 for business visas. The visas were issued in a mass
production like assembly line of immigration officers and took less than
five minutes from the time one handed in ones passport till the time the
passport and visa were handed back. All in all a very efficient and helpful
approach to encouraging both tourists and businessmen.
Cambodia is aggressively promoting tourism and both in Phnom Penh
and in Siem Reap new hotels are coming up. Cambodian, Thai and to a lesser
extent Western investments in travel infrastructure are particularly large
near Angkor Wat and the Khmer temple complexes. In general, although service
is still not up to Thai standards of friendliness and efficiency, the hotel
and tourism sector is definitely growing and improving daily. For those of
you who still are delaying your visit to Cambodia because of a fear of crime
or violence, forget your fears. The central government has carried on an
extensive program of weapons turn-ins and other measures. Guns are rarely
seen on the streets and crime is very much down. Although travelers at night
are advised not to walk alone in many areas of the city at night, these same
admonitions are also true of many western cities.
Cambodia struck me as being open and receptive for business. Most
of the businessmen we met spoke English and expressed a desire to work with
us. Streets were being paved and new services inaugurated. One observer
noted the government’s policy on import of automobiles. Cambodia is a very
poor country – one of the worlds poorest - and most Cambodians don’t have
the funds to buy new automobiles or motorcycles. Vietnam has a similar
problem but the Vietnamese government response was to prohibit import of
used vehicles and require companies to open auto plants there. Many did and
many lost big money because of their ill-advised investment. Cambodia looked
at Vietnam’s effort and also the fact that Thailand is next door and is the
regional center for automobile production for all of Southeast Asia. From
its observation, it concluded that Cambodia couldn’t compete with Thailand
and that attempting to require automobile companies to relocate there
wouldn’t work. The government also concluded that prohibiting import of used
automobiles and spare parts would be unfair and just encourage black
marketing. The government response was thus to allow imports of used
vehicles and spare parts which created a vibrant market and has led to
imports, sales and to government revenue where none existed before. This
non-doctrinaire and flexible approach is true of much government economic
policy and is to be lauded. Corruption continues to be a considerable
problem but is no worse than in Vietnam or Indonesia and perhaps less
predatory in many ways. The government is stable with the CPP Political
Party controlling most levers of power throughout the country.
In business, one is still struck by the lack of large industry in
Cambodia. Textile factories have gone through a boom and bust expansion and
are expanding again despite labor unrest caused in large part by
International Labor Organization activities. Although this labor
organization effort was started with good intentions, it is in many cases
short sighted and naïve in its approach. Thankfully the majority of other
business is non-unionized and totally free market. Cambodian workers
look at a $60 U.S. dollar a month salary as a good salary for unskilled
work. The number of educated officials and businessmen has definitely been
impacted by Cambodia’s history. Oftentimes if the people you are dealing
with are in their 30s or 40s chances are they are probably Russian educated.
Below this, most of the educated labor pool is young recent French educated
graduates or even local graduates because of the virtual elimination of the
educated elder generation by Pol Pot and the Khmer Rouge. Expect to have to
restructure your plans in the event you choose to do business here to bring
in Thai or Filipino managers and to look to Vietnamese and other workers for
some of your skilled employees. Also, figure on a much-reduced level of
productivity from your Cambodian staff and more need for training. Changing
a travel reservation can often take up to thirty minutes and don’t expect
the idea will transfer the first time even if you do speak the language.
One surprise I received during our stay in Phnom Penh was the extent to
which Vietnamese and Chinese are spoken. I had expected that Cambodian
language would be dominant, followed by Thai because of Thailand’s long
involvement in Cambodia. Instead what I found is that the Vietnamese are
everywhere and often fill secretarial, accounting and service jobs
throughout the economy. These Vietnamese say there is some animosity against
them by local Cambodians and oftentimes that they are harassed by the police
but in general they seem able to work and this government policy again
appears well reasoned as they often fill important mid level positions in
many companies.
Additionally, I was shocked to the extent that Mandarin Chinese is
spoken. During our stay, I spoke Mandarin with our driver, plus heard it
spoken by numerous tour groups and business delegations. Over a drink that I
was invited to share when a group of Chinese businessmen learned of my
ability to speak their language, I was told that Chinese businessmen are now
looking for investments in Cambodia and are traveling there frequently. My
host who was from Shanghai noted that the countries limited population an
agricultural base were some of its attractions and implied that the Chinese
government supports this policy.